Nicolai Meyer proved his strength in the decisive moments. In the 2023/24 season, Meyer scored in overtime in the seventh game of the semi-final against Bolzano to secure the Red Bulls a place in the final. In the fifth game of the final against the KAC, he scored another overtime goal to give EC Red Bull Salzburg the series lead and played a key role in winning the title with two more goals in the seventh game. In total, he scored five goals and six assists in the 19 playoff games of the win2day ICE Hockey League.